On the morning Randy's Donuts opened in Santa Clara, two friends had a plan for the lines. One stood in line at Stan's and the other at Randy's. Then they needed somewhere to compare. The Mercury News reported that another customer pointed across the parking lot to a corner business and offered "Taco Bell!" as neutral ground.
That was July 31. Three months later, the corner of Homestead Road and Las Palmas Drive still has two doughnut shops across from each other. The rivalry got the headlines. For anyone ordering doughnuts for Thanksgiving week, the more useful point is that the two shops sell different things, and the older one runs on a calendar you have to plan around. Stan's posts two closures over the holiday: Thanksgiving, November 26, and Black Friday, November 27. So the last chance at a Stan's dozen before the long weekend is Wednesday, November 25.
Two Shops Built for Different Orders
The two storefronts have more in common than people expect. The Mercury News found that both businesses date to the 1950s, and that both sell more of the glazed raised doughnut than anything else. They differ in nearly everything else.
| Stan's Donut Shop | Randy's Donuts | |
|---|---|---|
| Address | 2628 Homestead Road | 2595 Homestead Road |
| Roots in Santa Clara | Opened April 1959 | Opened July 31, 2026 |
| Glazed raised, July 2026 | $1.90 | $2.75 |
| Single doughnut range, August 2026 | $1.25 to $3 | $2.75 to $4.55 |
| Menu style | Classic, rarely changes | Up to 50 flavors and varieties |
| Payment | Cash only | Online ordering and catering links |
Stan Wittmayer, a World War II veteran, started the shop with his wife Florence in 1959. All nine of their children worked there at one point or another, and the Wittmayer family still owns it. Julie Clark, the founders' youngest daughter, runs it today. Randy's comes from the other end of the state. CEO Mark Kelegian told the Mercury News the Southern California company goes back to 1952, stayed family-owned for decades, changed hands, and now franchises. The Santa Clara store is owned by three partners, one of them Ausaf Masud of Campbell.
Why Stan's Takes Cash and Sells by the Dozen
Clark explained how her shop works in an August interview with Palo Alto Online:
"We're a volume shop. We get dozens and dozens ordered at a time. I think more specialty doughnut shops, they might do more like half a dozen, and their fancier doughnuts are a little bit more exotic. Where we're doing dozens for meetings or events, family gatherings, things like that."
Stan's is cash only and plans to stay that way, because cash keeps the line moving at busy times and keeps costs down, which keeps prices low. The recipes haven't changed, and the doughnuts are still cut and glazed by hand. The hand-painted menu signs, by artist Luis Filipe Villafuerte, are more than 50 years old. Clark calls the shop "kind of the In-N-Out of doughnuts."
A shop built for big orders also has an ordering system. Stan's menu page says it takes phone orders 24 to 48 hours ahead during business hours. The menu leads with the "Famous Glazed," and apple fritters are made only on Mondays and Fridays. The shop is open daily from 6 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., and the number is 408-296-5982.
Randy's arrival also showed how many people rely on Stan's. Clark told Palo Alto Online that business picked up a little the week before Randy's opened and "exploded" on opening day. Most of the people in her line were longtime customers. The Silicon Valley Voice reported that a Valley Medical Center physician was picking up doughnuts for his team that day. That's the kind of order Clark described.
The Week of November 23 on Homestead Road
The holiday calendar on Stan's homepage lists closures and no special hours. For Thanksgiving week, the dates fall like this:
- Monday, November 23. It's a fritter day, and the only one that week, since the other regular fritter day is Black Friday.
- Monday or Tuesday. The 24-to-48-hour phone-order window for a Wednesday pickup falls here.
- Wednesday, November 25. Stan's last day before the holiday, with the usual 2:30 p.m. close.
- Thursday, November 26, and Friday, November 27. Closed for Thanksgiving and Black Friday.
- Saturday, November 28. Not on the closure list.
The same list says Stan's is closed on Christmas Day and New Year's Day, so the rest of the holiday season has two more dates to work around. Bring cash, and if you're ordering a few dozen for a gathering, call before you go.
Randy's Covers the Afternoon
Randy's is set up for a different part of the day. Kelegian told the Mercury News that Randy's shops stay open later than most doughnut shops so people can get sweets in the late afternoon or after dinner. Besides doughnuts, they sell breakfast sandwiches, coffee drinks and refreshers. The Santa Clara store's location page lists 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. daily. Its hours have changed since opening, so check them before a holiday trip. In August, Masud told Palo Alto Online that opening weekend went through about 6,500 doughnuts a day and sold out hours before the 9 p.m. close. He cut hours until production caught up.
The menu covers the novelty end. Palo Alto Online listed raised doughnuts in mango Tajín, matcha, Fruity Pebbles, s'mores and Nutella, plus giant Texas doughnuts and Crondies, a croissant-doughnut. The Mercury News added Maple Bacon Long Johns. Randy's site links to online ordering and catering for the store. Masud told the Mercury News the partners picked the former KFC building for its big kitchen and the chance to reopen the drive-thru lane, which few properties have. He expects "healthy competition," with customers going to Stan's one day and Randy's the next. "It's double the doughnut fun," he said.
Clark sees it the same way. "Randy's has their own style where they do have different things going on and just different flavors than we would have," she told Palo Alto Online. On opening day, a customer who had tried both told the Silicon Valley Voice that Randy's has "a lot more selection." For Thanksgiving week, that puts Stan's dozen on a Wednesday deadline. Randy's posts later hours and sells a wider range of flavors.
The Rest of the Holiday Calendar Nearby
A few other Santa Clara holiday dates fall around the doughnut runs:
- Saturday, November 21. The Triton Museum of Art's free Holiday Art Fair runs 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. at 1505 Warburton Ave., with artist booths, baked goods and live carolers.
- Friday and Saturday, November 27 and 28. San José Made's Holiday Fair fills the Santa Clara Convention Center at 5001 Great America Pkwy. from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. both days. Admission is free, and organizers expect more than 350 makers. The first day falls on Black Friday, one of the two days Stan's is closed.
- Friday, December 4. The city's Holiday Tree Lighting runs 5:30 to 8 p.m. at Central Park, 909 Kiely Blvd., with Santa, food, holiday music, local performances and children's activities.
- Friday and Saturday, December 4 and 5. Santa Clara University's 27th Annual Festival of Lights starts at 7:30 p.m. at Mission Santa Clara, with the university's Chamber Singers and Concert Choir.
Hosting family over Thanksgiving and want to know more about the neighborhoods your guests ask about between doughnuts? Sunaina Arora follows the Santa Clara blocks around Homestead Road closely and is glad to share what she's seeing. If you've ever wondered what your own place is worth, get your instant home valuation.